Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Working with JSON Web Tokens

JSON Web Tokens (JWTs) have become a popular choice for implementing secure authentication and authorization in modern web applications. Their compact, self-contained nature makes them ideal for transmitting user information between parties. However, as with any technology, improper implementation can lead to vulnerabilities and performance issues. To help you make the most of JWTs while avoiding common mistakes, we’ve compiled a list of pitfalls to watch out for when working with JSON Web Tokens.

1. Using Weak or No Signing Algorithm

One of the most critical aspects of JWT security is the signing algorithm. A common mistake is using weak algorithms like HS256 (HMAC with SHA-256) without proper key management or, worse, using none as the algorithm. The none algorithm essentially disables signature verification, leaving your tokens vulnerable to tampering.

How to avoid this:

• Always use a strong signing algorithm, such as RS256 (RSA with SHA-256) or ES256 (Elliptic Curve with SHA-256).
• If you’re using symmetric algorithms like HS256, ensure your secret key is long, random, and securely stored.
• Never allow the none algorithm unless you have a very specific and secure use case (which is rare).

---

2. Failing to Validate Tokens Properly

A common oversight is assuming that a JWT is valid simply because it exists. Without proper validation, attackers can craft their own tokens and gain unauthorized access to your system.

How to avoid this:

• Always validate the token’s signature to ensure it hasn’t been tampered with.
• Check the token’s claims, such as iss (issuer), aud (audience), and exp (expiration), to ensure they match your application’s requirements.
• Use libraries or frameworks that handle token validation securely and efficiently.

---

3. Not Setting Token Expiration (exp)

JWTs are stateless, meaning they don’t rely on a server-side session. While this is convenient, it also means that tokens can remain valid indefinitely unless an expiration time is explicitly set. This can lead to security risks if a token is stolen or leaked.

How to avoid this:

• Always include an exp (expiration) claim in your JWTs to limit their validity period.
• Use short-lived tokens (e.g., 15 minutes to 1 hour) and implement refresh tokens for prolonged sessions.
• Regularly rotate signing keys to invalidate old tokens.

---

4. Storing JWTs in Insecure Locations

Where you store your JWTs can significantly impact the security of your application. Storing tokens in insecure locations, such as local storage or cookies without proper precautions, can expose them to attacks like cross-site scripting (XSS) or cross-site request forgery (CSRF).

How to avoid this:

• Prefer storing JWTs in secure, HTTP-only cookies to protect them from XSS attacks.
• If you must use local storage, ensure your application is free from XSS vulnerabilities.
• Implement CSRF protection mechanisms if you’re using cookies for token storage.

---

5. Overloading the Payload with Sensitive Data

JWTs are base64-encoded, not encrypted. This means anyone with access to the token can decode its payload and view the claims. Storing sensitive information, such as passwords or personally identifiable information (PII), in the payload is a serious security risk.

How to avoid this:

• Only include non-sensitive, minimal information in the token payload.
• If you need to transmit sensitive data, encrypt it separately before including it in the token.
• Use claims like sub (subject) or user_id to reference sensitive data stored securely on the server.

---

6. Ignoring Token Revocation

Since JWTs are stateless, there’s no built-in mechanism to revoke them once issued. This can be problematic if a token is compromised or if a user logs out and the token remains valid.

How to avoid this:

• Implement a token blacklist or revocation list to track and invalidate compromised tokens.
• Use short-lived tokens combined with refresh tokens to minimize the impact of token theft.
• Consider using a centralized authentication server to manage token revocation effectively.

---

7. Not Securing Token Transmission

Even if your JWT implementation is flawless, transmitting tokens over insecure channels can expose them to interception and theft via man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks.

How to avoid this:

• Always use HTTPS to encrypt token transmission between the client and server.
• Avoid sending tokens in URLs, as they can be logged in browser history or server logs.
• Use secure headers like Authorization: Bearer <token> for transmitting tokens.

---

8. Failing to Monitor and Log Token Usage

Without proper monitoring, it’s difficult to detect suspicious activity or misuse of tokens. This can leave your application vulnerable to attacks.

How to avoid this:

• Log token usage, including issuance, validation, and revocation events.
• Monitor for unusual patterns, such as repeated failed validation attempts or tokens being used from unexpected locations.
• Use tools like rate limiting and IP whitelisting to mitigate abuse.

---

Conclusion

JSON Web Tokens are a powerful tool for securing modern web applications, but they must be implemented with care to avoid common pitfalls. By following best practices—such as using strong signing algorithms, validating tokens properly, setting expiration times, and securing token storage—you can ensure your JWT-based authentication system is both robust and secure.

Remember, security is an ongoing process. Regularly review your implementation, stay updated on the latest security practices, and be proactive in addressing potential vulnerabilities. By doing so, you’ll be well-equipped to leverage the benefits of JWTs while keeping your application and users safe.